Wellington roads need tolls for cars

5 08 2010

It seems the NZTA is to waste another $29 million dollars on State Highway 1 between Aotea Quay and the SH1/SH2 split, which is barely more than 3 kilometres. It seems maybe someone working at the NZTA on Victoria Street doesn’t like the congestion as they drive to work as the sole occupant of their car each morning. So the Dom Post reports that the  safety lanes, aka shoulder lanes, may be used on the motorway as real lanes. Road infrastructure is just so bloody expensive, it’s a wonder why Treasury hasn’t called a halt to such flagrant money wasting. Wellington doesn’t need to reward people from Porirua, Tawa and the Hutt for driving to work by giving them more lane space. Instead Wellington should disincentivise them to drive in and forcing $29 million of treasure to be wasted on a peak need that lasts for less than an hour in each of the morning and evening.

Instead it should incentivise travel on the train by improving service, including the frequency of the services, and the Great Harbour Way should be built to make it safe to ride from the Hutt to Wellington, and it should put a helmetless bike share scheme in place to get you from the Railway Station to wherever you need to go. And it should fund all of that by tolls.

Road tolls already exist in New Zealand. The Northern Gateway road leading north out of Auckland is already tolled. See http://tollroad.govt.nz/. The Tauranga Eastern Link is going to be funded by tolls. And if Transmission Gully ever gets built it too is most likely to be tolled.

A small toll, say $2, should be enforced for anyone coming into Wellington on a weekday morning and anyone leaving Wellington on a weekday afternoon. One electronic toll booth would be put in the Ngauranga Gorge, and another on the Hutt Road. Because they only operate on one side of the road, morning or afternoon, then if you were driving from the Hutt and up the Gorge you would only get pinged once. The tolls wouldn’t be on the SH1 motorway at, say, just north of the Aotea Quay on ramp and off ramps, since that would only encourage toll avoidance onto the Hutt Road in Kaiwharawhara and it certainly doesn’t need any extra traffic.

Those $2 tolls could then be used to fund transport projects that aren’t road projects. If the Great Harbour Way was actually built to a decent standard and it was then safe to cycle from the Hutt to Wellington, what is the pent up demand? How many new cyclists would it encourage? How many fewer cars would then be on the road? That wasted $29 million will never need to be spent.

It's not peak hour so there's not enough traffic to justify spending $29 million.

We could end up with a 6 lane highway all the way to Petone if we really wanted to, but do we really want to live in a city of motorways and vehicle emissions, or would we rather live in a city with bike paths and cleaner air?




5 responses

8 08 2010
Patrick Morgan

I agree.
Want to take this debate to the next level? Ask Dom Post if you can contribute a column along these lines.

13 08 2010
Ideas for Wellington #2 thru #11 « Wellington Region Cycleways

[…] is funded by the users of the services (such as tram and gondola passengers, and bike hirers) and  by tolling congestion creating cars using the motorways in peak […]

8 10 2010
Electric bike share « Wellington Region Cycleways

[…] important Safe bicycle infrastructure should be well funded and well designed and extensive Roads should be tolled Bike share schemes should be made to work, and they should be integrated into a city’s public […]

27 12 2010
The Kaiwharawhara Shambles « Wellington Region Cycleways

[…] compromised Hutt Rd bike infrastructure is that it is an absolute shambles. And whilst it seems no expense will be spared on the Motorway any money spent on bike infrastructure seems a long way off. In fact the whole of the north side of […]

11 04 2011
We can’t build our way out of congestion « Wellington Region Cycleways

[…] On a day when the NZTA has been accused of bullying it is perhaps time to comment on the NZTA’s call for public comments on the section of State Highway 1 between Aotea Quay and Ngauranga. Does anyone know what they are trying to justify for that section of road? I’ve commented before on this section of motorway when I heard they were going to spend another $29 million dollars on usurping the emergency stopping lanes on this post here. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: